Admissions | Faculty | Contact Us | Jobs | Monarch
Crop SciencesCollege of Agricultural, Consumer, and Environmental Sciences |
| 321 210th Ave. Monmouth, Illinois 61462 Phone & Fax: (309) 734-7459 |
Eric A. Adee Pr. Research Specialist e-mail: adee@illinois.edu |
Marty Johnson Research Specialist |
| FEBRUARY WEATHER: | Soil Temperature (oF) | |||
| Air Temp. (oF) | Humidity (%) | 4" (Bare) | 4" (Sod) | |
| Monthly Average High | 38.6 | 90.6 | 32.5 | 31.5 |
| Monthly Average Low | 18.6 | 48.6 | 29.0 | 29.9 |
| Observed High (date) | 64 (8) | 100 (several) | 42 (11) | 34 (19) |
| Observed Low (date) | -23 (15,16) | 28 (6) | 16 (5) | 23 (5) |
| Month | Monthly Total |
Monthly Departure from Average |
Since January 1 Total Accumulation |
Since January 1 Total Departure |
|
| January | 0.27 | -1.35 | 0.27 | -1.35 | |
| February | 2.43 | +0.71 | 2.70 | -0.64 | |
There have been several aspects of continuous corn management studied at NWRC the last several years. While it is assumed that continuous corn needs to be managed differently than rotated corn, what needs to be different? Hopefully, summaries of the following studies can offer some light on the subject.
One continuous corn study involved tillage, fertility, and population. From 2003-07, the fall tillage comparison was between conventional (chisel plow) and a modified moldboard plow. The fertility included a normal level of 220 lb N with recommended P and K based on soil tests, and a high level with an additional 100 lb N (70 applied sidedress at V12-14), 80 lb P and 150 lb K. The two plant populations were 32,000 and 40,000 plants/acre. Hybrids with rootworm Bt (RwBt) were planted in 2006 and 2007.
| 32,000 Plt Pop |
40,000 Plt Pop |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Tillage | Fertility | Yield (bpa) | |
| Conv. | 220 lb N | 175 | 159 |
| 320 lb N + PK | 181 | 176 | |
| Mod. Plow | 220 lb N | 186 | 182 |
| 320 lb N + PK | 192 | 189 | |
The modified moldboard did increase the yield of continuous corn 14 bushels per acre (bpa) compared to the chisel plow (Table 1). Residue counts after planting averaged 59% with the chisel and 35% with the modified moldboard. Getting some of the residue off the soil surface appears to have helped the yield.
The higher level of fertility increased the yield 9 bpa over the normal fertility, although the increase would need to be more than 45 bpa to pay for the additional fertilizer bill.
The higher population actually decreased yield 7 bpa. This suggests that ultra-high plant populations do not guarantee higher yield, and in this case they did not handle the stress as well.
This study was modified in 2008, changing the tillage to include fall strip-till instead of the modified moldboard. Fungicide application at tasseling replaced the population factor. The two fertility levels stayed the same. Data are 2008 averages from four U of I research centers, DeKalb, Monmouth, Orr Center, and Urbana. Hybrids with RwBt were used at all centers.
| No Fungicide |
With Fungicide |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Tillage | Fertility | Yield (bpa) | |
| Conv. | 220 lb N | 199 | 207 |
| 320 lb N + PK | 213 | 220 | |
| Strip-Till | 220 lb N | 205 | 215 |
| 320 lb N + PK | 214 | 223 | |
Strip-till yielded an average of 4 bpa better than conventional tillage with a chisel plow (Table 2). The high level of fertility added 11 bpa, but again not enough to pay for the extra fertilizer. The fungicide treatment increased yield 9 bpa across all locations. At Monmouth, the residue counts diagonally across the field after planting were 72% in the conventional tillage and 86% in the strip-till.
A second study compared the effect of tillage and residue removal on the yield of continuous corn. The two tillages compared were conventional with fall chisel plowing and no-till. The no-till had no tillage other than the coulters of the liquid N application at 3 to 4 inches deep. Residue removal treatments after harvest included 1: All- residue removal(chopping with a batwing mower, raking and baling the stalks), 2: 1/2 residue removal (raking and baling the stalks), and 3: no residue removal. Nitrogen rates had been knifed into plots prior to planting (data not included).
| Corn Residue Removal Level | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| All | 1/2 | None | |
| Tillage | Yield (bpa) | ||
| Conv. | 253 | 252 | 254 |
| No-till | 247 | 242 | 226 |
| LSD 0.10 = 22 bpa | |||
There were no differences between corn yields at any of the residue levels with conventional tillage (Table 3). With no-till, the yield with no residue removed was significantly lower than all the other treatments, while those with all or 1/2 of the residue removed were not different from the yields in conventionally tilled soil. The residue levels at planting in 2008 were 18, 23, and 68% respectively for all, 1/2 and no residue removed before conventional tillage. In no-till, the residue cover was 48, 53, and 93%, respectively, all, 1/2, and no residue removal.
In a crop rotation study, non-RwBt hybrids were planted 2002-05 and RwBt 2006-08. In continuous corn the non-RwBt averaged 99 bpa and the RwBt averaged 197 bpa. For comparison, the corn/soybean rotation non-RwBt averaged 177 bpa and RwBt 208 bpa.. While there were environmental differences in the comparison of hybrids, (e.g. amount of rain in different years) the yield differences were much greater between the hybrids for the continuous corn than the rotated. It has been observed that the continuous corn yields across NWRC have been more consistent and closer to the yield of rotated corn since the introduction of RwBt hybrids.
Following are a few observations that can be made from these results.